Showing posts with label Federal Reserve. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Federal Reserve. Show all posts

Tuesday, February 13, 2018

Traditionally Hawkish Loretta Mester Signals "Stay the Course"

Cleveland Fed President Loretta Mester, in speaking to the Dayton Area Chamber of Commerce this morning, signaled a "stay the course" attitude regarding the Fed's current interest rate policy.  Her speech follows a week of extremely turbulent price action in the markets, raising speculation that volatility in the DOW would influence the Fed's pace of interest rate hikes through the remainder of the year.

The market has currently priced in three interest rate hikes for 2018, and sentiment shows a 77.5% chance of a 25 bps increase following the March 21 FOMC meeting.  Mester, one of the hawkish members of FOMC, said today that she supports a rate increase pace similar to what the Fed pursued in 2017 when they raised interest rates three times over the course of the year. 

Mester dismissed the current market action as little more than the normal correction one would expect after the explosive run-up in stock prices experienced over the past year.  “For now," she said,  "I expect the economy will work through this episode of market turbulence and I have not changed my outlook. In my view, the underlying fundamentals supporting the economy are very sound.”

 Historically, Mester has supported an aggressive interest rate policy, citing fears of a run-up of inflation should the Fed not raise rates quickly enough.  While she expects inflation to rise at an increasing rate, she does not foresee a need to increase the rate at which the Fed raises rates.  It's noteworthy that her remarks come a day before the February release of the closely watched CPI numbers.  Tomorrow's numbers should be a strong signal both for inflation's rate of change and for the aggressiveness the Fed is likely to take for the remainder of 2018.

The consensus for tomorrow's CPI release, according to Econoday is as follows:

PriorConsensusConsensus Range
CPI - M/M change0.1 %0.3 %0.3 % to 0.4 %
CPI - Y/Y change2.1 %2.0 %1.9 % to 2.3 %
CPI less food & energy- M/M change0.3 %0.2 %0.1 % to 0.3 %
CPI less food & energy - Y/Y change1.8 %1.7 %1.7 % to 2.0 %

Numbers that come in stronger that the consensus will add pressure to an already jittery market since it will increase speculation that the Fed will add a fourth rate increase into 2018.  That fourth increase is not currently factored into prices.

Mester also addressed the impact the 2018 tax cuts may have on the economy as a whole.  In her view, she expects the cuts to add between a quarter and a half of a percent to economic growth.  This, she expects, will support an inflationary rate just above the Fed's target of 2.0%.  It should also, in her view, support continued hiring in the private sector.  That will spur an increase in wage growth, the primary factor driving inflation.  (Wage growth in January increase 0.3% over December, and is showing an already strong annual 2.9% hourly rate.)

Scott Anderson, chief economist at Bank of the West in San Francisco, doesn't share the view that inflationary growth is under control.  “The acceleration in average hourly earnings growth punches a hole in the narrative that wage growth remains lackluster.  The Goldilocks view of inflation is being sorely challenged right now.”

Wednesday and Thursday provide a series of economic releases that will signal Fed's direction.  Definitely watch tomorrow's CPI release.  If there's surprise to the upside, expect the market to react negatively in anticipation of a more aggressive interest rate schedule.  But it doesn't end with the CPI.  Watch these releases tomorrow and Thursday for a more complete picture:
  • Wed - 8:30 AM - CPI
  • Wed - 8:30 AM - Retail Sales
  • Thu - 8:30 AM - Jobless Claims
  • Thu - 8:30 AM - Philadelphia Fed Business Outlook Survey
  • Thu - 8:30 AM - PPI FD
  • Thu - 9:15 AM - Industrial Production
 We share Mester's view that the fundamentals of the economy remain strong.  The question, however, is "how strong."  By market open on Thursday, we should have a good idea as to whether the economy is too strong or if it's proceeding at a healthy pace.

Happy Trading.

Wednesday, December 14, 2016

Markets Adjusting for Rate Hike and Yellen's Hawkish Press Conference

Today's quarter-point increase in the Fed Funds rate came as no surprise to anyone.  What followed, however, was the most hawkish press conference Fed Chair Janet Yellen has delivered in her brief tenure.  The official FOMC Press Release was issued at 14:00 EST.  As expected, the release cites continued strength in the labor market as well as moderate expansion in the overall economy. 
The Fed expects inflation to continue to rise gradually towards their 2% target: "Inflation is expected to rise to 2 percent over the medium term as the transitory effects of past declines in energy and import prices dissipate and the labor market strengthens further."  Remember that, in Fed Speak, "medium term" is defined as between two and six years.

It's important to note that today's vote to increase rates was unanimous. Up until this point, there were at least three staunch doves voting against any rate hikes.  That it was unanimous signals a shift in the overall tenor of the committee and may be a harbinger of a more aggressive monetary policy going forward.

The significant change in today's policy announcement comes in the forecast for additional rate increases over the next three years.  Prior to today's announcement, the market was anticipating two quarter-point interest rate hikes in 2017.  The signal today, however, is for three.  Now, Ms. Yellen did caution that not all members are on board with that projection.  As a result, we can anticipate more volatility than usual around the monthly key data releases since the market will need to assess how the FOMC members will interpret the data and how that will influence a potential rate hike in March.  We're likely back into a "good news is bad" scenario where positive economic data creates a selloff out of fears of an additional rate hike.

In her post-announcement press conference, Ms. Yellen acknowledged some of the challenges facing the job market while issuing a veiled caution that the political rhetoric may not match the actual causes.  She specifically mentioned increased technology and automation as significant factors in workforce reduction saying, "For decades the pace of technological change in manufacturing has outstripped that of the economy as a whole. So manufacturing firms have found it easier to continue producing by reducing their work forces."  In other words, the problem is not all due to outsourcing and bad trade deals. Changes in the overall technical infrastructure are major contributing factors, and this rapid rate of change will be a fact of life for the foreseeable future.

On several occasions, the questions offered ample opportunity to opine on the President-Elect and the policies of the incoming administration.  To her credit, the Fed Chair refused to take the bait.  Specific to Mr. Trump's statement that he would not reappoint her, she offered, "I do intend to serve out my four-year term. I haven't made any decision about the future. I recognize I might or might not be reappointed. It's a decision I don't have to make and don't have thoughts on at this time."

 She took the opportunity to repeat several times that the independence of the Fed is a concept with which she fully agrees, and also pointed out that the 4 year term of the Fed Chair is not coterminous with the 4 year Presidential Term.  She made it a point of saying that it was setup this way for a reason, and that it was a very solid practice that has served the nation well.

When pressed on the stock market, she stated, “We’re operating under a cloud of uncertainty at the moment.” Her comments were an acknowledgement that the interpretation of the post-election surge in stock prices represented an expectation of lower corporate taxes, lower regulations, and an overall business friendly environment.  That's the popular interpretation of what we're seeing, however it's not an interpretation I share.  Rather, I believe we're seeing the natural market reaction to the resolution of uncertainty - i.e. the extremely contentious US presidential election - coupled with growing consumer confidence heading to the period of a traditional Santa Claus Rally.  In my view, the post-election surge we're seeing would have occurred regardless of the winner.  It's doubtful that there is this much movement based on the anticipation of what Congress will end up doing with taxes and regulations following at least a full year of debate. 

One factor that the market will weigh over the coming weeks is the impact of the new Fed projections for interest rate targets through 2018.  Both years are now tracking higher in projections than they were a day ago. The median projection for 2017 is now 1.375% (up from 1.155%) and 2018 saw a similar increase to 2.125%.  The target for 2019 is 3.00%. 

Interestingly, Ms. Yellen's opening statement made no mention of the global economic environment.  That comes as a bit of surprise on the heels of Mario Draghi's statements in last week's ECB announcement, coupled with the specter of the potential Article 50 Brexit invocation in the first half of 2017.  Her only mention of the historically low comparable price of oil was in the context of it being transitory: "As the transitory influences of earlier declines in energy prices and prices of imports continue to fade, and as the job market strengthens further, we expect overall inflation to rise to 2 percent over the next couple of years."

All three US major stock indexes retreated following Ms. Yellen's press conference.  We can expect to see a bit of volatility over the next few days as the market digests what FOMC has forecast for the coming year.  In addition, be ever mindful of the stock market truism, "buy the election; sell the inauguration."  Of course, volatility provides excellent short-term trading opportunities, so we'll be closely watching what develops as we head into the end of the year.

Happy Trading

Wednesday, July 13, 2016

Fed Continues to Signal Patience on Interest Rates

Two of the Federal Reserve presidents that sit on the Federal Open Markets Committee (FOMC) had appearances scheduled this morning.  These one-off speeches are followed by traders, however it's important to bear in mind that they represent the views of the individual voting (or non-voting, in some cases) member and do not represent the FOMC as a whole.  What's more important is following any change in tone respective to the individual.

Dallas Fed President Robert Kaplan confirmed what was reported a couple of days ago related to growth, and said he expects the GDP to continue in the 2% range for the year.  He expressed the view that this growth rate is very slow, and considers boosting growth to be the most important economic issue we are currently facing.  Without going into details, he said that doing so would require some structural changes that are outside of the mandate afforded the Federal Reserve.  That would appear to be a not-so-veiled nudge to Congress related to trade and growth stimuli.

Providing a brief glimpse into the thinking of FOMC as a whole, Kaplan also stated that the Federal Reserve is "very sensitive" to the strength of the US Dollar.  Indeed, this one statement is the best signal we have that interest rates will remain low for the foreseeable future since any rise in rates would further strengthen the dollar to the detriment of US exports and to the earnings of US companies with heavy overseas exposure.  Until the entire Brexit issue is resolved and we start to understand the new dynamic in Europe, it's unlikely that the US dollar will weaken.

Meanwhile, Minneapolis Fed President Neel Kashkari spoke at a Town Hall meeting in Marquette, Michigan.  He directly addressed interest rates, saying, "We feel like we can be patient to let the economy continue to heal before we start moving aggressively to raise rates. We should take our time when we go ahead and start raising rates again. There's not a huge urgency to raise rates because inflation is coming up low."

His wording suggests that he's expressing the views of FOMC, not just his own, and it's consistent with what we've been hearing from the other Fed Presidents over the last couple of weeks.  It's interesting to note Kashkari's focus on inflation, compared to Kaplan's focus on the strength of the dollar.  By definition, a monetary "Hawk" is primarily interested in maintaining inflation at the Fed's mandated 2% target.  A "Dove" by contrast, is focused primarily on unemployment (and other non-inflationary factors) with an interest in maintaining unemployment under 5%.

Kashkari is a newcomer to FOMC, replacing the extremely dovish Narayana Kocherlakota in November, 2015. It's important to note that Minneapolis (and thus, Kashkari) will not be a FOMC voting member until 2017.  Still, hearing Kashkari take a hawkish position focused on inflation gives us some insight into where he will fall in the economic spectrum next year.  (The categorizations of hawks favoring interest rate hikes and doves favoring holding rates low are not accurate categorizations of the terms.)

While Kashkari is currently siding with the doves regarding keeping interest rates low, he also stated that he sees moderate growth ahead.  Whether that's above the 2% cited by Kaplan is unknown, but few would consider that level to be "moderate growth."  He made it a point of saying that he does not foresee a recession and does not believe the Fed will have to ease monetary policy.  (Following the dismal job numbers from May and a decline in the GDP in that period, there was some discussion of lowering interest rates or even introducing a new round of Qualitative Easing, although the June numbers have pushed those thoughts to the background again.  Kashkari clearly rejects the notion of either.)

FOMC holds their next meeting the 26th and 27th of July, with their next announcement scheduled for 2:00 PM on the 27th.  The futures market shows a 0% chance of an interest rate hike in either July or August, and only a 12% chance of a rate hike in either September, October, or November.  The odds of a rate hike jump to 30% in December, however that's more of an indication that anything can happen over the next five months.  We now have some analysts projecting the next rate hike as late as June, 2017.

For short-term traders, it does mean that we will not have artificial volatility over the next couple of months based on interest rate speculation.  It also means that dividend players will have very limited exposure going into 2017.  (Remember, higher interest rates put selling pressure on lower-yield stocks.)  We'll be interested in the FOMC release more as a gauge of what pressures the Fed sees over the next quarter both here and abroad, however at least in the July meeting we don't anticipate any signal that interest rate talk will heat up any time soon.